Best Restaurants in the Hamptons

The Hamptons, a string of seaside communities known for their affluence, pristine beaches, and cultural sophistication, also boasts an impressive culinary scene. From cozy bistros to high-end eateries, the variety of dining options caters to every palate, making it a paradise for food lovers. Whether you're a local, a summer visitor, or a potential homeowner exploring the area, indulging in the Hamptons' best restaurants is a must. Here’s a curated list of top dining spots defining the Hamptons' flavor and allure.

Nick & Toni's – East Hampton

A beloved fixture in East Hampton, Nick & Toni's offers a warm, inviting atmosphere coupled with a menu that celebrates local and seasonal ingredients. Known for its celebrity sightings and rustic-chic vibe, this eatery serves up Mediterranean-inspired dishes with an emphasis on farm-to-table freshness. Don't miss their wood-fired pizzas and the legendary zucchini chips.

The American Hotel – Sag Harbor

This historic restaurant, located within The American Hotel dating back to 1846, provides a quintessential Hamptons dining experience. With its classic decor, the restaurant offers a refined menu featuring French and American cuisine. The wine list is as impressive as the food, having won multiple awards for its depth and quality.

Duryea's Lobster Deck – Montauk

For those seeking a truly iconic Hamptons experience, Duryea's Lobster Deck is unmatched. Famous for its lobster rolls and breathtaking views of Fort Pond Bay, Duryea’s offers a casual yet unforgettable dining experience. Enjoy their seafood-centric menu while watching the sunset for an idyllic evening.

The Palm – East Hampton

Located in the historic Huntting Inn, The Palm is renowned for its sumptuous steaks and jumbo Nova Scotia lobsters. This outpost of the famous steakhouse chain maintains a charming Hamptons feel with caricatures of local celebrities adorning its walls, adding a unique touch to the dining atmosphere.

Jean-Georges at Topping Rose House – Bridgehampton

This relatively newer addition to the Hamptons dining scene quickly made its mark with Jean-Georges Vongerichten at the helm. The menu blends local farm produce with the chef’s signature French-Asian influences, resulting in beautifully crafted dishes that are both innovative and delicious. The setting in a restored 19th-century mansion adds to the luxurious dining experience.

Le Bilboquet – Sag Harbor

Bringing a slice of French sophistication to Sag Harbor, Le Bilboquet is famed for its vibrant atmosphere and impeccably curated French cuisine. Signature dishes include the Cajun chicken and the endive salad with Roquefort cheese. Its dockside location offers stunning waterfront views, making it a perfect spot for summer dining.

Scarpetta Beach – Montauk

Located in Gurney's Montauk Resort, Scarpetta Beach is the coastal version of the famed Manhattan Italian eatery. The restaurant offers a rich selection of seafood and Italian classics, with a focus on fresh ingredients and bold flavors. The ocean views and chic decor provide a backdrop that complements the exquisite culinary experience.

The 1770 House – East Hampton

For those who appreciate history mixed with modern American cuisine, The 1770 House is ideal. This restaurant and inn, set in a colonial building from 1770, offers an elegant menu crafted by Chef Michael Rozzi. Specializing in dishes that incorporate local seafood and artisanal ingredients, it also boasts a more casual tavern downstairs.

Cowfish – Hampton Bays

Perfect for family dining, Cowfish features an American cuisine menu with a Southern twist. Situated on the Shinnecock Canal, its outdoor seating area provides panoramic water views. Their menu offers everything from ribs and burgers to fresh oysters, appealing to all tastes.

Stone Creek Inn – East Quogue

A hidden gem in East Quogue, Stone Creek Inn offers a tranquil escape with its charming ambiance and a menu that highlights the best of local produce. Chef Christian Mir’s French background influences the dishes, creating a delightful fusion of local flavors with classic French techniques.

Culinary Delights Meet Luxury Living

Exploring the Hamptons' dining scene offers more than just a taste of local cuisine—it provides a glimpse into the lifestyle that makes this area so desirable. Whether you're considering a visit or thinking about making a more permanent move, understanding the culinary delights of the Hamptons can significantly enrich your experience.

Partner with a Local Expert

If the allure of the Hamptons' lifestyle captivates you, partnering with an expert who understands both the real estate and local culture can enhance your journey. Lori Schiaffino of the Schiaffino Team offers unparalleled expertise in navigating the Hamptons real estate market. With Lori's guidance, you can find your perfect home in this coveted locale and immerse yourself fully in the luxurious Hamptons lifestyle. Explore your options—contact Lori Schiaffino and start your journey to a dream home in the Hamptons today!

Work With Us

All with extensive business experience, the Schiaffino Team brings a wealth of local knowledge and understanding of the Hamptons’ real estate market.