Two $15 million houses south of Montauk Highway in Bridgehampton mark the two ends of this year's market. One is the 6,500-square-foot cedar-shingle farmhouse at 53 Matthews Lane, designed in 2016 by Bridgehampton architect Kitty McCoy and set on 1.5 acres. It closed on Sept. 24, 2026 at its full asking price of $15.25 million, less than two years after it last sold for about $13.5 million, according to Behind the Hedges. The other, still on offer, is a 9,100-square-foot spec house that Mercer Built is putting up on Toppings Field Court, a cul-de-sac south of the highway. It is asking $15 million and is expected to be finished in spring 2027, Behind the Hedges reported in August.
The newer house is 40 percent larger, and the older one cost slightly more. The difference comes down to time. In Bridgehampton, a buyer pays the premium for a finished house to avoid years of design, permits and construction. That premium has grown large enough that a well-built house from the last decade can trade like new construction. It also explains much of this year's sharp jump in the median price reported for Bridgehampton and Sagaponack, which reflects a change in which houses sold more than a rise in every house's value.
Two Ways to Spend $15 Million South of the Highway
| 53 Matthews Lane | Toppings Field Court | |
|---|---|---|
| Status | Closed Sept. 24, 2026 | Spec house under construction, due spring 2027 |
| Price | $15.25 million, full ask | $15 million asking |
| Living space | About 6,500 sq ft | More than 9,100 sq ft |
| Land | 1.5 acres | 0.93 acres |
| Bedrooms | Five | Seven |
| Approx. price per sq ft | About $2,350 | About $1,650 |
The two houses differ in more than age, and land explains part of the gap: Matthews Lane has half an acre more of it. Its grounds were designed by Water Mill's LaGuardia Design Group, 27east noted. The Toppings Field Court house has an elevator connecting three levels, a gym and wellness room, a 20-by-50-foot heated gunite pool with spa, and a cabana with a full bath. Mercer Built's principal, Justin Marinoff, told Behind the Hedges that his team took down an old farmhouse on the site. They saved its chimney bricks and its long, wide pine floorboards to reuse in the new house. Marinoff estimates that about half of the roughly 20 projects his firm takes on in a year are spec houses.
Builders keep putting up spec houses because buyers keep paying for them. Even so, the Matthews Lane sale shows that the market valued a finished house designed a decade ago at a higher price per square foot than a larger new one due in about six months.
The Clock Behind a New Build
The premium makes more sense once you count what it replaces. Social Life Magazine estimated in December 2025 that a custom Hamptons house costs $800 to more than $2,000 per square foot for construction alone. Premium-quality work runs $900 to $1,200 per square foot, ultra-premium $1,200 to $1,600, and trophy level $1,600 to $2,500 or more. By the same estimate, construction is only 55 to 65 percent of a project's total cost, before land, soft costs and finishing.
At the ultra-premium rate, a house the size of Matthews Lane would cost about $7.8 million to $10.4 million to build, before land and everything else. Time is the bigger cost. The same estimate puts the full span from land purchase to move-in at 30 to 54 months. A buyer who closes on a lot this November should therefore expect to move in somewhere between May 2029 and May 2031. That is two to four summers spent renting or waiting. A buyer of a finished house gets to use it next summer.
Seen this way, the full-ask sale on Matthews Lane is ordinary. The buyer paid for 2027, 2028 and possibly 2029 in the house, plus the certainty that what they saw was what they would get.
What Bridgehampton Brokers Say Buyers Are Pricing
Brokers working in the hamlet described the same pattern in two roundtables this year. In May, Bridgehampton broker Jake Colucci told Behind the Hedges that "many buyers are no longer looking simply for new. They want something well done and turnkey." He added that a house "of a size that could not be built again today" is often the kind "going for big numbers and setting records." In the same piece, Bridgehampton broker Paul Brennan said inventory was building in the $8 million to $15 million range, but "true turnkey product, especially new construction, remains in short supply."
By September, the list of features buyers expect in a finished house had grown. Bridgehampton broker Marilyn Clark told Behind the Hedges that "very few people want to take on a major renovation project." She said pickleball and padel courts, saunas, cold plunges and gyms are in high demand, and that buyers are paying stronger prices in areas that have not traditionally been as sought after when the house itself works for them. In the same roundtable, East Hampton broker Michael Petersohn spelled out the other side: "Buyers will pay a premium for convenience, but they will not pay a premium for someone else's unfinished project." He listed what buyers forgive least: major structural work, unresolved permits, missing certificates of occupancy, aging septic systems and pools that need rebuilding.
None of those items is cosmetic. Each one adds time and an unknown cost, the same burden the turnkey premium spares the buyer.
Why the Quarterly Median Jumped
Bridgehampton's 2026 numbers look different with that in mind. Corcoran's third-quarter East End report combines Bridgehampton and Sagaponack. In July through September 2026, the combined area had 20 single-family closings, down from 30 in the same quarter of 2025. Over the same period, the median price rose from $4.825 million to $7.55 million, an increase of 56 percent. The average rose 59 percent to $9.475 million. Total dollar volume rose only 6 percent, to $189.5 million. The combined area also had nine luxury sales, the most of any South Fork submarket that quarter.
Houses in the two hamlets did not gain 56 percent in a year. Ten fewer homes changed hands, and the ones that did skewed toward large, finished, high-end houses. Fewer sales at a higher price per sale is what that change in mix looks like. The second quarter shows a calmer version of the same shift: 14 closings at a $5.95 million median, according to the same Corcoran report. William Raveis's second-quarter figures, which 27east reported, cover a wider Bridgehampton market area that includes Water Mill and Sagaponack. They put the April-through-June median at $5.33 million, up 12.2 percent from a year earlier. Three of the quarter's seven Hamptons sales above $20 million were in Bridgehampton. Across the whole Hamptons, The Real Deal reported that third-quarter 2026 sales fell 9 percent from a year earlier.
Where a Project House Fits
The turnkey premium has a mirror image in what buyers pay for houses that need work. Bridgehampton's 2026 sales show both ends. In February, 6 Cody Way, an estate of nearly 10,000 square feet in the equestrian corridor, sold for $10.018 million. In March, 130 Hildreth Avenue, a village house south of the highway next to a four-acre reserve and with room to expand, sold for $3.528 million.
Recorded transfers this fall show where the middle of the market traded. 27east's Deeds & Transfers listings show Bridgehampton closings in September 2026 of $3.325 million at 207 Snake Hollow Road, $3.8 million at 63 Chester Street and $3.995 million at 163 Millstone Road. Others were $4.5 million at 196 Oak Street, $5.85 million at 523 Pauls Lane, $6.21 million at 2462 Montauk Highway and $6.6 million at 481 Brick Kiln Road. The span from about $3.3 million to $6.6 million in a single month reflects how widely condition, land and location vary inside one zip code.
For a house that needs work, the discount has to pay for the years of design, approvals and building, along with the risk of surprises once the walls are open. A project house is fairly priced only when the gap between its price and a finished comparable covers the construction budget, two or more summers without the house, and a reserve for whatever the inspection did not find. Petersohn's phrase from the September roundtable fits: renovation opportunities sell "only when price acknowledges the time, cost and inevitable surprises involved." In Bridgehampton, where the earlier agricultural reserve post showed how much of a property's value comes from its setting, location is the one thing a renovation budget cannot change.
Timing matters as well. Speaking about the North Fork in the same Behind the Hedges roundtable, broker Melissa Principi said some of her best deals come together around Thanksgiving, when motivated sellers may prefer to negotiate rather than carry a property through the winter. For a Bridgehampton buyer this week, that window applies to both kinds of house. A seller of a finished house may be weighing another winter of carrying costs, and a seller of a project house knows that every month of waiting is a month the next buyer must add to their own construction schedule.
Whether the right Bridgehampton house is finished now, due in spring 2027 or still waiting for its renovation, the decision depends on weighing price against time, and that comparison is specific to each street. The Lori Schiaffino Team can price the turnkey premium and the renovation discount on the Bridgehampton properties you are considering, including new construction still underway, and give you a discreet valuation if you are weighing a sale this winter. Work With Us.