The Best Neighborhoods for a Second Home in the Hamptons

The Hamptons, located on the eastern end of Long Island, is a prestigious enclave known for its beautiful beaches, exquisite homes, and a lifestyle that blends seaside charm with luxury living. Choosing the best neighborhood for a second home in the Hamptons depends on your lifestyle preferences, budget, and what you want from your experience. Here’s a guide to the top neighborhoods in the Hamptons, each offering its unique allure.

East Hampton: The Quintessence of Luxury

East Hampton is synonymous with luxury and history, home to some of the most coveted properties in the Hamptons. It offers a perfect mix of beautiful beaches, high-end boutiques, fine dining, and a rich cultural scene, including the Guild Hall and the East Hampton Historical Society. The neighborhood is ideal for those seeking an elegant and sophisticated Hamptons experience, with easy access to both nature and upscale amenities.

Southampton: Classic Charm Meets Modern Elegance

Southampton, one of the oldest and largest communities in the Hamptons, is known for its historic homes, stunning beaches, and vibrant village life. Its main street is lined with designer boutiques, art galleries, and gourmet restaurants, making it a bustling hub for both locals and visitors. Southampton offers a blend of old-world charm and modern luxury, making it a prime location for those looking for a lively yet refined second home.

Sag Harbor: A Nautical Haven

Sag Harbor, with its rich maritime history, offers a more laid-back and bohemian vibe compared to its more polished neighbors. This former whaling port boasts a charming Main Street, waterfront restaurants, and a vibrant arts scene. The neighborhood is perfect for those who appreciate a strong sense of community and history, with a penchant for sailing and waterfront living.

Montauk: The Ultimate Beach Retreat

Montauk, situated at the very tip of Long Island, is known for its rugged natural beauty, surf culture, and laid-back atmosphere. It's a haven for outdoor enthusiasts, offering some of the best surfing, fishing, and hiking in the region. Montauk provides a more relaxed and casual setting, ideal for those looking to escape the more manicured landscapes of the Hamptons for a beachy, bohemian vibe.

Water Mill: A Serene Escape

Water Mill offers a more tranquil and understated Hamptons experience. This neighborhood is characterized by its lush landscapes, agricultural heritage, and exquisite waterfront properties. It's a great spot for those seeking privacy and serenity, away from the hustle and bustle of the more crowded villages. The area is also home to cultural gems like the Parrish Art Museum, adding a touch of sophistication to the rural setting.

Bridgehampton: A Blend of Country and Coastal Living

Bridgehampton strikes a balance between country charm and coastal sophistication. Known for its beautiful beaches, horse farms, and vineyards, it offers a diverse range of activities from equestrian events to wine tasting. The neighborhood boasts a mix of historic homes and modern architecture, appealing to those who enjoy a rural aesthetic with the conveniences of upscale dining and shopping.

Amagansett: The Relaxed Beach Town

Amagansett is favored for its laid-back lifestyle and beautiful, unspoiled beaches. It has a small-town feel with a tight-knit community, offering a mix of casual eateries, boutique shopping, and local arts and music. Amagansett is ideal for families and individuals seeking a quieter, more relaxed pace of life in the Hamptons, with the added benefit of gorgeous beachfront scenery.

Sagaponack: Exclusive and Secluded

Sagaponack, known for its sprawling estates and agricultural landscapes, is one of the most exclusive and expensive neighborhoods in the Hamptons. Its rural charm, combined with the privacy it offers, makes it a coveted location for those seeking an ultra-luxurious and secluded second home. The area's beauty is enhanced by its vineyards, farms, and the stunning Sagg Main Beach.

Wainscott: The Best of Both Worlds

Wainscott, nestled between East Hampton and Sagaponack, offers a quiet, family-friendly atmosphere with convenient access to the amenities of its bustling neighbors. It features a beautiful mix of farmland, beaches, and quaint village life. Wainscott is perfect for those who want a peaceful retreat close to the action of the Hamptons' social scene.


Choosing the right neighborhood for a second home in the Hamptons is about finding the perfect balance between personal preferences, lifestyle, and budget. Each area has its unique charm and character, from the luxurious and historic estates of East Hampton to the relaxed, beachy vibe of Montauk.

Whether you're looking for a bustling village center, a serene rural escape, or a beachfront paradise, the Hamptons offer a diverse range of settings to create your ideal second home. By understanding the distinct qualities of each neighborhood, you can make an informed decision that aligns with your vision of the perfect Hamptons retreat.

Embark on your journey to find the perfect Hamptons hideaway with the experts who know it best. Connect with The Lori Schiaffino Team and tap into the pinnacle of Hamptons real estate expertise. Whether you're seeking a serene beachfront bungalow or a grandiose estate among the tranquil lanes, The Lori Schiaffino Team will guide you to your dream second home with their unmatched local knowledge and dedicated service. Visit their website today to start crafting your Hamptons legacy with the finest in the field!

Work With Us

All with extensive business experience, the Schiaffino Team brings a wealth of local knowledge and understanding of the Hamptons’ real estate market.