Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

32 Old Montauk Highway

32 Old Montauk Highway, NY, Montauk 11954

32 Old Montauk Highway


32 Old Montauk Highway, NY, Montauk 11954

Ocean breezes, spectacular sunsets, and unmatched luxury unfold at this impeccably built traditional sited on a picturesque 1.58 acres. Perched on a hillside, with unobstructed views overlooking "Deep Hollow Ranch" where the horses quietly graze, rests a private retreat in a highly coveted location. Few newly constructed Montauk offerings compare to the magnificent tranquil setting and impressive lifestyle of this exquisite 5 bedroom, 6+ bath gem boasting stunning interiors, outdoor fireplace, a sparkling crystal blue pool and spa with pool house for the ultimate resort-style enjoyment. Step inside the gracious cedar shake beauty to find a light and airy modern floorplan spanning 5,054 square feet, with every detail meticulously thought out. Your dream home comes complete with a massive great room that feels warm and welcoming thanks to a towering floor-to-ceiling brick fireplace. Enhancing the ambience are soaring ceilings, and a wall of picture windows with glass doors that slide open for effortless poolside entertaining. Whip up culinary delights in the striking gourmet kitchen wrapped in top-of-the-line appliances and custom cabinetry; mix craft cocktails from the huge thick-slab-marble island; serve meals in the elegant dining room with easy access outdoors; or escape to the secluded screened-in porch for tranquil views of farm fields and sky. Completing the main level is a private den area leading outside, and luxurious primary bedroom suite with vaulted ceiling, glass doors to the outside oasis, and a stunning high-end spa bath with dual sinks and enormous glass-encased shower. Upstairs also invites comfort with additional sleeping quarters, featuring a second master bedroom suite with spectacular bath accentuated by an oval soaking tub, plus 2 guest bedroom suites with their own stunning full baths and walk out decks. As a great added bonus, there's yet another bedroom suite that sits above the garage with bright open loft-like space, affording a welcomed sense of privacy. The spacious lower level with vaulted ceilings has room for two additional bedrooms. Whether you want to experience the culture and history of Montauk at Third House where Teddy Roosevelt spent his time or soak in the rugged dramatic shoreline of the cliffs, Montauk gives you a unique lifestyle. Home to some of the most iconic names in the art world such as Andy Warhol, Julian Schnabel and Peter Beard this surf town is beyond compare. Exclusive and extremely serene, this turnkey jewel awaits you.

Key Details

  • 5,054 Sq.Ft.
  • 2018
  • Year Built: 2018
  • Lot Size: 1.58 Acres
  • Flooring: Hardwood Floors
  • Pool: Gunite Pool
  • Interior Features: Master Bedroom, Family Room, Hot tub, Exercise Room

Features & Amenities


Total Bedrooms 5
Total Bathrooms 7
Full Bathrooms 6
Half Bathrooms 2
Flooring Hardwood Floors
Other Interior Features Master Bedroom, Family Room, Hot tub, Exercise Room


Stories 2
Garage Space 2
POOL Gunite Pool
Heat type Fireplace
Air Conditioning Central AC
Other Exterior Features Outdoor Showers

Area & Lot

Status Sold
LOT SIZE 1.58 Acres
MLS® ID 355151
Type Residential
Year Built 2018
Neighborhood Montauk


SALES PRICE $5,800,000

Perched on a hillside, with unobstructed views overlooking Deep Hollow Ranch

Lor Schiaffino



Montauk has been home to many of the most iconic artists and collectors of our time.

Read more

Work With Us

All with extensive business experience, the Schiaffino Team brings a wealth of local knowledge and understanding of the Hamptons’ real estate market.