Montauk Homes for Sale | The Schiaffino Team

Welcome to Montauk

Montauk has been home to many of the most iconic artists and collectors of our time, and truly considered the coolest place to be in the Hamptons. Since the 60’s, Montauk is where so many artists like Andy Warhol, Mick Jagger, Keith Richards, Julian Schnabel, Peter Beard, John Lennon and Yoko Ono chose to spend their long summer days. Rich in history and inspiration to many, the Rolling Stones even wrote Memory Motel in homage to the Montauk joint of the same name. Billy Joel wrote his classic, Downeaster Alexa, and continues to spend his time cruising the shores of Montauk.

People & Lifestyle

Anyone who loves to fish, surf, relax on the beach, or spend time by the sea will find something to love about Montauk. Known for its cool hip vibe and with over 70% of its land preserved, Montauk is one of the most beautiful places on earth.

Art & Culture

People don’t mind taking the extra ride out to Montauk to enjoy the unique seaside dining experiences. The following are a few of the best-known options in their respective categories.

Dining

The Crow’s Nest is a great place to dine and stay during the summer months, serving a menu of unique seafood dishes and great vegetable sides, The Crow’s Nest is a one of a kind location on West Lake Drive. Enjoy a cocktail while soaking in the sunset with family and friends.
The Inlet is known for its locally-caught seafood and incredible sushi menu. Only serving takeout until 6:30PM, this waterside restaurant shouldn’t be missed.
Gosman’s Topside is a fun place to watch the boats come in and out of the harbor. Serving a menu full of both raw and cooked locally caught seafood options, this venue is perfect for lunch or dinner.
Duryea’s waterfront seating is the definition of dinner with a view. This seafood restaurant combines casual comforts with upscale sensibilities. Not to be missed!

Shopping

Whalebone located next to Duryea’s serves up the coziest gear for the whole family. Be sure to go back often as inventory is constantly changing - keeping it fresh.
The Endz Salon is a great salon just steps away from the beach. Offering a variety of beauty services from hair and nails to makeup, The Endz Salon will have you ready for any occasion.
The Shipwreck is a jewelry and gift store new to the Montauk area. The store features nautical-themed jewelry as well as custom bridal sets.
Gosman’s Dock touts a gourmet fish market with both locally-caught seafood and international delicacies flown in daily.
For designing your dream home, head to Indy Home. This interior design shop blends timeless styles with current trends.

Things to Do

When you are looking for things to do in Montauk, there are many options. For the following activities, these are the best places to go.

Surfing

Ditch Plains Beach, is the ultimate surf break for beginners and veterans. Lifeguards are on duty during the summer, and there are concession trailers available.

Boating

Gurney's Star Island Resort & Marina is the perfect place to go for summer getaways and seasonal yachting. Situated on Lake Montauk, Gurney’s Star Island Resort & Marina is ranked among the top ten marinas in North America.

These are all the neighborhoods where The Lori Schiaffino Real Estate Team is active

Montauk Real Estate

Lori Schiaffino and her team are the leading experts in all things Hamptons real estate. Contact us to learn more about our real estate services in the Hamptons or browse our selection of Montauk homes for sale below.

Montauk, NY Real Estate FAQ

1. What is the current real estate market like in Montauk, NY?

The real estate market in Montauk, NY is somewhat competitive, so it's essential to check with a local real estate agent for the most up-to-date information.

2. What is the average home price in Montauk, NY?

The average home price in Montauk, NY varies depending on the neighborhood and property type. As of December 2023, Montauk homes were selling for a median price of $2.7M, but it's crucial to consult a local realtor for the latest figures.

3. What neighborhoods are popular in Montauk?

Popular neighborhoods in Montauk include Ditch Plains, Culloden Point, and Hither Hills. Each offers unique features and a distinct coastal living experience.

4. Are there good schools in Montauk?

Montauk is served by Montauk School, providing education for elementary and middle school students. For high school, students often attend schools in nearby areas. Check with local school districts for the latest information.

5. What amenities and attractions are available in Montauk?

Enjoy a range of amenities in Montauk, including pristine beaches, hiking trails, and world-class fishing. The area is known for its lighthouse, Montauk Point State Park, and vibrant dining and shopping scene.

6. Is Montauk a safe place to live?

Montauk is considered a safe place to live, the crime rate is relatively low compared to other cities of its size. However, crime rates can vary by neighborhood, so it's advisable to research specific areas and consult local law enforcement for the latest safety information.

7. What is the commute like to and from Montauk?

Commuting in and out of Montauk can vary due to its location at the eastern tip of Long Island. The area is accessible by road and rail, and the scenic drive offers breathtaking views.

8. How can I find a real estate agent in Montauk, NY?

Premier Montauk real estate agents in The Schiaffino Team provides concierge-style services to make the home buying and selling process easier for clients.

9. Are there any special considerations for buying property in Montauk, NY?

Special considerations for buying property in Montauk may include understanding coastal regulations, reviewing flood zones, and being aware of the impact of seasonal tourism on property values. Consulting with a local real estate professional like The Schiaffino Team can help you navigate these considerations.

10. Can I find both single-family homes and condos in Montauk, NY?

Yes, Montauk offers a variety of housing options, including charming single-family homes and some condominiums, particularly in beachfront areas. Explore different neighborhoods to find the property type that suits your preferences.

Remember that the real estate market is subject to change, so it's crucial to consult with a local real estate expert for the most accurate and current information regarding Montauk, NY. The Schiaffino Team can keep you informed and help you save time, every time throughout the entire real estate process!

Overview for Montauk, NY

4,272 people live in Montauk, where the median age is 51.8 and the average individual income is $76,857. Data provided by the U.S. Census Bureau.

4,272

Total Population

51.8 years

Median Age

Low

Population Density Population Density This is the number of people per square mile in a neighborhood.

$76,857

Average individual Income

Demographics and Employment Data for Montauk, NY

Population Households Employment

Montauk has 1,571 households, with an average household size of 2.65. Data provided by the U.S. Census Bureau. Here’s what the people living in Montauk do for work — and how long it takes them to get there. Data provided by the U.S. Census Bureau. 4,272 people call Montauk home. The population density is 231.04 and the largest age group is Data provided by the U.S. Census Bureau.

4,272

Total Population

Low

Population Density Population Density This is the number of people per square mile in a neighborhood.

51.8

Median Age

56.13 / 43.87%

Men vs Women

Population by Age Group

0-9:

0-9 Years

10-17:

10-17 Years

18-24:

18-24 Years

25-64:

25-64 Years

65-74:

65-74 Years

75+:

75+ Years

Education Level

Less Than 9th Grade
High School Degree
Associate Degree
Bachelor Degree
Graduate Degree

1,571

Total Households

2.65

Average Household Size

$76,857

Average individual Income

Households with Children

With Children:

Without Children:

Marital Status

Married

Single

Divorced

Separated

Blue vs White Collar Workers

Blue Collar:

White Collar:

Commute Time

0 to 14 Minutes

15 to 29 Minutes

30 to 59 Minutes

60+ Minutes

Around Montauk, NY

There's plenty to do around Montauk, including shopping, dining, nightlife, parks, and more. Data provided by Walk Score and Yelp.

19

Car-Dependent

Walking Score

30

Somewhat Bikeable

Bike Score

Points of Interest

Explore popular things to do in the area, including Bambi's Cafe, Adam Mar Clothing, and Susie E Montauk Fishing Charter.

Name	Category	Distance	Reviews	Ratings by Yelp
Visit the Bambi's Cafe page on Yelp Search 33 Carl Fisher Plz on Google Maps	Dining	0.92 miles	10 reviews	5/5 stars
Visit the Adam Mar Clothing page on Yelp Search 54 S Erie Ave on Google Maps	Shopping	0.75 miles	5 reviews	4.8/5 stars
Visit the Susie E Montauk Fishing Charter page on Yelp Search 352 W Lake Dr on Google Maps	Active	1.4 miles	8 reviews	5/5 stars
Visit the Adios Fishing Charter page on Yelp Search 470 W Lake Dr on Google Maps	Active	1.86 miles	5 reviews	5/5 stars
Visit the Sail Montauk page on Yelp Search 478 West Lake Dr on Google Maps	Active	1.9 miles	35 reviews	5/5 stars
Visit the MTK Cruises page on Yelp Search 59 Star Island Rd on Google Maps	Active	1.79 miles	23 reviews	5/5 stars
Visit the Hither Hills State Park page on Yelp Search Old Montauk Hwy on Google Maps	Active	4.34 miles	5 reviews	4.8/5 stars
Visit the Double D Fishing Charters page on Yelp Search W Lake Marina on Google Maps	Active	0.93 miles	5 reviews	4.8/5 stars
Visit the Montauk Cycle Boat page on Yelp Search 470 Westlake Dr on Google Maps	Nightlife	1.86 miles	5 reviews	5/5 stars

Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

Montauk

Featured Homes for Sale

11 Chauncey Close V1

11 Chauncey Close V2

104 Georgica Close Road

11 Chauncey Close

34 Cobb Isle Road

67 Hither Lane

26 Wainscott Main Street

73 Wainscott Stone Road

900 Head of Pond Road

176 Two Holes of Water Road

311 Georgica Road

19 Roberts Lane

900 Head of Pond Road

27 Howard Street

89 Cobb Road

47 On The Bluff

15 Fieldview Lane

35 Hampton Road

1333 Sagg Road

13 Peter's Path

202 Hedges Lane

24 Red Fox Ln

27 Edwards Ave

29 Oyster Pond Lane

30 Cobb Isle Road

31 Davids Lane

343 Sebonac Road

348 Millstone Brook Road

373 Mitchells Lane

46 Baiting Hollow

475 David Whites Lane

493 Parsonage Lane

4 Fedak Lane

54 Hedges Banks Drive

55 Post Crossing

5 Amagansett Drive East

628 Head of Pond Road

629 Little Bird Road

641 Little Bird Road

73 Pleasant Lane

88 Dune Road

9 Hardscrabble Close

Welcome to Montauk

People & Lifestyle

Art & Culture

Things to Do

These are all the neighborhoods where The Lori Schiaffino Real Estate Team is active

Montauk Real Estate

Montauk, NY Real Estate FAQ

1. What is the current real estate market like in Montauk, NY?

2. What is the average home price in Montauk, NY?

3. What neighborhoods are popular in Montauk?

4. Are there good schools in Montauk?

5. What amenities and attractions are available in Montauk?

6. Is Montauk a safe place to live?

7. What is the commute like to and from Montauk?

8. How can I find a real estate agent in Montauk, NY?

9. Are there any special considerations for buying property in Montauk, NY?

10. Can I find both single-family homes and condos in Montauk, NY?

Overview for Montauk, NY

4,272

51.8 years

Low

$76,857

Demographics and Employment Data for Montauk, NY

4,272

Low

51.8

56.13 / 43.87%

1,571

2.65

$76,857

Around Montauk, NY

19

Car-Dependent

30